Most common Craftsman tiller parts that may need replacing
Craftsman tillers are built to tackle tough soil, but even the most durable models need replacement parts over time. One of the most frequently replaced Craftsman tiller parts is the tiller tines. These rotating blades break up compacted soil to prepare garden beds. When they become dull, bent, or worn out, they can’t churn the soil effectively and may cause uneven tilling. If you need help with the process, follow our guide on how to replace the tines on a front-tine tiller or how to replace the tines on a rear-tine tiller, depending on your model.
Another common replacement part is the clevis pin, which secures the tines to the rotating shaft. If the tines strike a rock or other solid object, the clevis pin may shear off to protect the tiller’s drivetrain. Replacing the clevis pin restores proper connection and tine movement.
The depth stake also sees wear over time. This component helps control how deeply the tines dig into the soil, and if it’s bent or damaged, it can lead to poor tilling performance or uneven rows.
If your starter cord won’t retract or the engine won’t engage, it may be time to replace the recoil starter. You can learn how to replace a tiller recoil starter with our step-by-step repair guide.
When it comes to Craftsman tiller replacement parts, Sears PartsDirect makes it easy to get what you need—whether it’s new tines, a fresh clevis pin, or a functioning recoil starter. Each component plays a key role in your tiller’s performance, especially during peak gardening season.
Common symptoms of Craftsman tiller problems
Narrowing down the problem is the first step to getting your tiller back in shape when it stops working. One common issue is when the tines turn but the wheels don’t, making it difficult to move the tiller forward. If you're dealing with this, our guide on what to do when your tiller's tines turn but the wheels don't can help you pinpoint the cause and fix it quickly.
You might also run into the opposite problem: the wheels spin but the tines stay still, which means your tiller won't dig into the soil. In that case, learn how to troubleshoot when your tiller's wheels turn but the tines don't.
Sometimes, the tiller seems completely unresponsive—neither the wheels nor the tines move when the engine’s running. This issue can be tricky to diagnose, but our resource on why your tiller's wheels and tines won’t turn walks through possible mechanical failures that may be causing the problem.
Even if the tiller moves and the tines rotate, poor soil performance can still be an issue. If you notice the machine isn’t breaking up the dirt like it used to, check out our guide on why your tiller might be turning the soil poorly. Worn tines, improper depth settings, or drivetrain issues can all play a role.
Sears PartsDirect provides trusted Craftsman tiller troubleshooting tips so you can find the right fix fast and get back to preparing your garden with confidence.
How to fix your Craftsman rototiller when the engine won't start
When your Craftsman tiller won’t start, it usually comes down to a few simple issues. Start by checking the fuel tank. Gasoline degrades over time, so if your tiller has been sitting for a season or longer, drain the old fuel and add fresh gasoline before trying to start the engine again.
Next, look at the choke setting. The choke must be closed during a cold start to help the engine pull in enough fuel. If the choke is open, the engine may crank but never turn over. Adjust it properly and try starting the tiller again.
A dirty air filter can also prevent the engine from starting. When the filter is clogged with dirt or debris, it restricts airflow to the carburetor, causing the engine to run too rich or not start at all. Remove the filter and clean it or replace it if needed.
Finally, inspect the spark plug connection. The wire must be securely attached to the spark plug to create the spark needed for ignition. If it’s loose, corroded, or damaged, the engine won’t start. Push the wire firmly onto the spark plug and check for signs of wear.
Following these basic troubleshooting steps can often resolve starting issues without needing a full teardown. If your tiller still won't run, further diagnosis may be necessary, but these quick checks solve the majority of no-start problems.
Get help with Craftsman tiller repairs
Keeping your tiller in top condition starts with having the right parts and the right guidance. At Sears PartsDirect, we carry a full range of Craftsman tiller parts to help you handle repairs on your own—whether you're replacing worn tines, swapping out a recoil starter, or troubleshooting why the engine won’t fire up.
Every garden tiller repair is easier with a little know-how. That’s why we offer detailed repair guides, expert troubleshooting advice, and maintenance tips written for do-it-yourselfers. If you’re not sure where to start, visit our DIY tiller repair help page for step-by-step instructions, helpful how-to articles, and everything you need to fix your Craftsman tiller with confidence.
Whether you're fixing wheels that won’t turn or replacing broken clevis pins, we’re here to make sure you get the right Craftsman rototiller parts and the right support every step of the way.
